Thursday night, 50 to 60 Medicine Hat residents gathered at Tracy’s Chocolate Shop. They came to talk about the Mustard Seed’s proposed 50 bed shelter on South Railway Street. Not one speaker supported the location. Not one.

I keep coming back to the Starlite Convenience owner. He says he is selling his store. Twenty five fights inside it. He cannot put women on the schedule alone for opening or closing anymore. That is not a talking point. That is a man losing his livelihood.

And I keep coming back to the organizer they call D. Fourteen cameras. Nearly 400 recordings. A teenage daughter who once had to respond to an overdose on their own front lawn. She will not use her name. I understand why.

Here is the question nobody with power will touch. Where is the line between the criminal element and the people who genuinely want rehab and a way forward? Every complaint out of that room was really about that line. Draw it, and the argument about addresses starts to solve itself. Refuse to draw it, and no location will ever work.

Drew Barnes stood up and said the quiet part loud. Rural but close. Local people running it, not the province, not the feds. Police enforce every theft, trespass, and vagrancy law on the books. Judges hold people accountable. You do not have to agree with everything he says to admit he named the disconnect.

The people doing the front line work in this are amazing. I would not last a day. The failure is not theirs. It is the policy and the politics above them. Catch and release, all the way down.

The MLA for the area did not come. He sent his manager. She never went inside. Draw your own conclusions about how seriously your representation takes you.

The dates that matter: Council gives first reading November 2. The public hearing is December 7. If you live near South Railway, those are your dates.

I will keep asking the question until someone answers it. Where is the line?

Have a story about what the shelter debate looks like from your street? Tell it at yourstory.justlovenobs.com.